On Friday, the Kansas Supreme Court ruled the states DUI testing refusal law unconstitutional, setting a remarkable precedent concerning forced testing of those suspected of driving under the influence.
In a 6-1 ruling, the court decided the states law, which had made it a crime to refuse breathalyzer or blood alcohol tests without a court-ordered warrant, is excessive punishment. Those tests, the court found, amounted to searches, and the Kansas law punishes people for exercising their constitutional right to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures, reported the Kansas City Star.
In essence, the states reasons are not good enough, and its law not precise enough, to encroach on the fundamental liberty interest in avoiding an unreasonable search, wrote Justice Marla Luckert for the majority, according to KCTV.
According to Kansas law, the act of operating a motor vehicle gives implied consent for breath, blood, or urine testing to prove ones sobriety, but the Supreme Court ruled the states Constitution allows for the withdrawal of consent without punishment for doing so.
Previously, refusing a sobriety test qualified as a misdemeanor, punishable by up to a year in jail and a fine of no less than $1,250.
Once a suspect withdraws consent, whether it be express consent or implied (under the statute), a search based on that consent cannot proceed, the court decided.
According to the court, the states compelling interest to combat impaired driving and prosecute cases of DUI does not trump peoples fundamental individual liberties as protected by the Constitution.
Justice Caleb Stegall wrote the lone dissenting opinion, saying there are certain situations where the law could adhere to constitutionality, and as such, it should be applied on a case by case basis.
By making this case about consent, Stegall wrote, the majority effectively looks at this appeal through the wrong end of the telescope and ends up with a myopic interpretation (of the statute).
There are similar laws from other states currently before the U.S. Supreme Court, and Kansas could potentially wind up under the high courts consideration as well.
In a related ruling, the Kansas Supreme Court also decided the case of an individual who consented to testing after being told he would be criminally prosecuted for refusing. According to the court, such a warning is considered coercive, thus any consent given in such circumstances would be involuntary.
Jay Norton, an Olathe criminal defense lawyer and expert on DUI law, said the law has often been used as a hammer to induce people to plead guilty to DUI to avoid being charged with the additional crime of refusing a test, reported the Star. Norton also said the law represented prosecutorial overreach at its zenith.
Christopher Mann, who sits on the national board of directors for Mothers Against Drunk Driving and is a former member of the Lawrence Police Department, said the organization didnt agree with the courts ruling.
We support penalties for refusing to take chemical tests, Mann explained. We think law enforcement members need to have all the tools at their disposal to keep our roads safe from drunken drivers who kill about 10,000 people a year.
The Supreme Court has affirmed the right of the individual citizen to be free from forced searches by the government, Norton stated.
Friday, Norton enthused, was a great day for both the Kansas and U.S. Constitutions.
#59: misterwhite To: A K A Stone (#48)
Really? Well if it's a right then everyone has that right, correct? Meaning everyone can drive a car, correct?
That's your position?
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-29 10:17:16 Reply Private Reply
#60: Roscoe To: misterwhite (#59)
Yep. They don't need no steenking licences or vehicle inspections.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-29 10:20:25 Reply Private Reply
#61: A K A Stone To: misterwhite (#59)
Yes, assuming you can operate the vehicle.
Assuming you haven't lost that right by drunk driving or something like that.
You are supposed to have the right to travel by the means of the day.
I believe you can lose that right of you do harm to others or put others life at risk.
But the starting point is you have that right. Certainly.
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 10:21:57 Reply Private Reply
#62: A K A Stone To: Roscoe (#57)
Looks like they are saying the same thing.
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 10:23:14 Reply Private Reply
#63: Roscoe To: A K A Stone (#62)
Bull crap!
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-29 10:24:02 Reply Private Reply
#64: A K A Stone To: Roscoe (#60)
I've never had my vehicle inspected. Except when taking drivers license test.
No you don't need a license to exercise a right. Certainly not.
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 10:24:23 Reply Private Reply
#65: A K A Stone To: Roscoe (#63)
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 10:26:04 Reply Private Reply
#66: misterwhite To: Roscoe (#60)
They have rights, dammit! And no one can infringe those rights with age restrictions and tests and licenses and stupid Rules of the Road.
If a drunk 10-year-old wants to hop in dad's car and hit the road, he has a God- given right to do so!
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-29 10:27:25 Reply Private Reply
#67: Roscoe To: A K A Stone (#64)
Your "right" to use the road built and maintained at public expense is limited to use in accordance with to the rules set for their use.
Didn't you just unintentionally admit that the "right" could be removed for drunk driving?
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-29 10:28:12 Reply Private Reply
#68: A K A Stone To: Roscoe (#63)
They say pretty much the same thing.
The state can not diminish the rights of the people.
That is common sense. Rights aren't privileges. So they can't be taken away. Duh
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 10:28:19 Reply Private Reply
#69: misterwhite To: A K A Stone (#65)
Well, there goes your argument.
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-29 10:28:25 Reply Private Reply
#70: A K A Stone To: misterwhite (#66)
You have a fifth amendment right to be secure in your papers person and effects.
That means they can't constitutionally pass a law requiring you to surrender those documents. Which they do in order to get a "license".
The difference between you and I. I belive in freedom.
You believe you unconstitutional government micromanagement and control over the people. It is as simple as that.
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 10:30:41 Reply Private Reply
#71: misterwhite To: Roscoe (#67)
That was done in post #65.
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-29 10:30:42 Reply Private Reply
#72: A K A Stone To: misterwhite (#69)
That means you have to stop at red lights, stop signs, and obey the speed limit.
It doesn't mean they can restrict your right to drive without you committing some kind of crime like DUI.
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 10:31:51 Reply Private Reply
#73: misterwhite To: A K A Stone (#70)
The how do illegals get driver's licenses?
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-29 10:33:01 Reply Private Reply
#74: Deckard To: A K A Stone (#70)
I can't help but wonder why a couple of dyed-in-the-wool statist shills would even want to post at a site called Liberty's Flame.
Those two yahoos have utterly no concept of liberty.
Deckard posted on 2016-02-29 10:33:50 Reply Private Reply
#75: A K A Stone To: misterwhite (#71)
It wasn't unintentional.
You can lose a right. If you say drive drunk and kill someone. Or if you drive drunk and put others in danger.
I have no problem with that.
It is my opinion and I believe supported by the constitution and common sense that you start with that right to travel by the means of the day. No government permission needed.
Like I said I already won in court over this years ago.
I do have a license and have had one for years. It's just less hassle that way.
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 10:34:19 Reply Private Reply
#76: misterwhite To: A K A Stone (#72)
WHAT??
The court ruled that the right may be regulated. They didn't limit the regulation to Rules of the Road.
Now you're just making shit up.
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-29 10:35:41 Reply Private Reply
#77: Roscoe To: A K A Stone (#65)
Nice foot shot.
By the way, have you ever read the actual decision?
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-29 10:37:07 Reply Private Reply
#78: A K A Stone To: Deckard (#74)
I understand. It is for fun. They like to talk about this stuff.
They are ok despite me calling one of them a pussy.
They are right on some issues. They just want the government to control us to much. They must live in fear of people with real freedoms.
I don't think they are bad or evil. They are just week and need to feel safe from real men who know what freedom is.
It is really a feminine characteristic. You know that need to be protected.
So I guess we could just say they are very feminine.
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 10:37:26 Reply Private Reply
#79: A K A Stone To: misterwhite (#76)
But not taken away and making you give up your documents in order to exercise that right. That would violate the fifth amendment.
Have you actually ever read the fifth amendment? '
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 10:39:04 Reply Private Reply
#80: Roscoe To: Deckard (#74)
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-29 10:39:10 Reply Private Reply
#81: Roscoe To: A K A Stone (#79)
That was a state court decision.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-29 10:40:05 Reply Private Reply
#82: A K A Stone To: Roscoe (#80)
Do you know the difference between law and color of law?
If a law violates the constitution is it really a law?
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 10:40:34 Reply Private Reply
#83: Roscoe To: misterwhite (#73)
Well, clearly, they have the right to print their own! Freedom!!!
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-29 10:41:28 Reply Private Reply
#84: A K A Stone To: Roscoe (#81)
There is a fifth amendment equivelant in every state.
Also the fifth amendment requires states to obey it.
There is no "congress shall make no las...." phrase in the fifth amendment.
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 10:41:41 Reply Private Reply
#85: Roscoe To: A K A Stone (#82)
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-29 10:43:30 Reply Private Reply
#86: Roscoe To: A K A Stone (#84)
So quote it. An actual quote, please.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-29 10:44:53 Reply Private Reply
#87: misterwhite To: Roscoe, A K A Stone (#53)
"I don't give a shit what some judge says."
-- A K A Stone
However, it appears as though A K A Stone does give a shit what some judge says when that judge agrees.
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-29 10:58:44 Reply Private Reply
#88: misterwhite To: A K A Stone (#79)
No proof is required to vote?
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-29 11:00:46 Reply Private Reply
#89: A K A Stone To: misterwhite (#87)
Yes when they agree with me they are right.
Because I seek and tell the truth.
It's not that a judge says it that I don't agree with. It is if they get it wrong I don't give a shit about what they say.
I do respect them when they get it right,
For example you like Judge Roberts and agree with all of his decisions.
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 11:03:19 Reply Private Reply
#90: A K A Stone To: misterwhite (#88)
Not until a couple of years ago.
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 11:04:16 Reply Private Reply
#91: A K A Stone To: Roscoe (#85)
That is incorrect. If you don't know that perhaps you should go back and get your GED.
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 11:05:02 Reply Private Reply
#92: misterwhite To: A K A Stone (#79)
Not only did I read it, I understand it.
"Self-incrimination is the act of exposing oneself to an accusation or charge of crime".
It has nothing to do with applying for a drivers license.
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-29 11:05:51 Reply Private Reply
#93: misterwhite To: A K A Stone (#90)
A "couple of years" being defined as "since 1950"?
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-29 11:08:52 Reply Private Reply
#94: misterwhite To: A K A Stone (#89)
But you and you alone define "right", correct?
Just curious. Do judges check with you before they render their decisions? You being the authority on right and wrong.
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-29 11:12:44 Reply Private Reply
#95: A K A Stone To: misterwhite (#93)
Until a couple of years ago here in Ohio.
But you make the point that the founders didn't think you need a license to vote.
Making my broader point.
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 11:18:46 Reply Private Reply
#96: A K A Stone To: misterwhite (#94)
I know the truth.
But it isn't because i'm magical.
It is because I read it honestly. I don't add or subtract.
No judges don't consult with me.
But if they did we wouldn't have Obamacare or a whole bunch of other unconstitutional pretend laws on the books.
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 11:21:09 Reply Private Reply
#97: Roscoe To: A K A Stone (#91)
Ahem.
Barron ex rel. Tiernan v. Mayor of Baltimore, 32 US 243 (1833)
Chief Justice Marshall, writing far the unanimous Court:
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-29 11:22:04 Reply Private Reply
#98: Roscoe To: misterwhite (#93)
And even earlier.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-29 11:25:09 Reply Private Reply
#99: A K A Stone To: Roscoe (#97)
However the fifth amendment talks about crimes that were not federal crimes at the time. It talks about things that were for the states.
The wording of the fifth amendment certainly says it applies to "all criminal" cases.
If you went back and got your GED you would learn what the word "all" means.
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 11:26:33 Reply Private Reply
#100: A K A Stone To: Roscoe (#98)
Maybe you need some remedial history lessons also.
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 11:27:12 Reply Private Reply
#101: A K A Stone To: Roscoe (#98)
You do agree that the money we have is illegal since congress only has power to coin money.
I'm sure you also agree that congress should set the value of the money as the constitution clearly requires.
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-29 11:29:04 Reply Private Reply
#102: Roscoe To: A K A Stone (#95)
Bzzzzt. Poll taxes. You not only could be required to obtain conditional permission, you could even be required to pay for that "right."
And you could be prevented from voting if you couldn't prove that you owned land.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-29 11:30:25 Reply Private Reply
#103: Roscoe To: A K A Stone (#100)
Those universally understood historic facts were never "ruled unconstitional." Which is why you couldn't provide a quote.
What Framer ever said that the Federal Bill of Rights was secretly a state Bill of Right?Roscoe posted on 2016-02-29 11:36:02 Reply Private Reply
#104: tpaine To: A K A Stone, y'all (#84)
ARTICLE VI, the Supremacy Clause, makes it clear that States are 'bound thereby' to obey the Constitution, and its amendments.
The "Congress shall make no law" line of the first amendment is deliberately misinterpreted by many statists like roscoe/misterwhite to mean that ALL of our rights are subject to State constitutional revisions.
This misinterpretation was corrected by the 14th Amendment, and is not, and never has been a rational argument..
tpaine posted on 2016-02-29 11:39:07 Reply Private Reply
#105: Roscoe To: A K A Stone (#101)
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-29 11:42:11 Reply Private Reply
#106: misterwhite To: A K A Stone (#95)
Since that decision has always been left to each state, the Founders had no opinion whatsoever.
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-29 11:50:01 Reply Private Reply
#107: tpaine To: A K A Stone, y'all (#99)
Marshall's decision in Barron must be viewed in a defense of slavery context. -- He was trying to prevent the civil war by claiming States could deny 5th amendment rights to slaves.
Apparently, roscoe/misterwhite still think this way..
tpaine posted on 2016-02-29 11:53:26 Reply Private Reply
#108: jeremiad To: misterwhite (#47)
jeremiad posted on 2016-02-29 17:55:08 Reply Private Reply