[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

"The Democrat Meltdown Continues"

"Yes, We Need Deportations Without Due Process"

"Trump's Tariff Play Smart, Strategic, Working"

"Leftists Make Desperate Attempt to Discredit Photo of Abrego Garcia's MS-13 Tattoos. Here Are Receipts"

"Trump Administration Freezes $2 Billion After Harvard Refuses to Meet Demands"on After Harvard Refuses to Meet Demands

"Doctors Committing Insurance Fraud to Conceal Trans Procedures, Texas Children’s Whistleblower Testifies"

"Left Using '8647' Symbol for Violence Against Trump, Musk"

KawasakiÂ’s new rideable robohorse is straight out of a sci-fi novel

"Trade should work for America, not rule it"

"The Stakes Couldn’t Be Higher in Wisconsin’s Supreme Court Race – What’s at Risk for the GOP"

"How Trump caught big-government fans in their own trap"

‘Are You Prepared for Violence?’

Greek Orthodox Archbishop gives President Trump a Cross, tells him "Make America Invincible"

"Trump signs executive order eliminating the Department of Education!!!"

"If AOC Is the Democratic Future, the Party Is Even Worse Off Than We Think"

"Ending EPA Overreach"

Closest Look Ever at How Pyramids Were Built

Moment the SpaceX crew Meets Stranded ISS Crew

The Exodus Pharaoh EXPLAINED!

Did the Israelites Really Cross the Red Sea? Stunning Evidence of the Location of Red Sea Crossing!

Are we experiencing a Triumph of Orthodoxy?

Judge Napolitano with Konstantin Malofeev (Moscow, Russia)

"Trump Administration Cancels Most USAID Programs, Folds Others into State Department"

Introducing Manus: The General AI Agent

"Chinese Spies in Our Military? Straight to Jail"

Any suggestion that the USA and NATO are "Helping" or have ever helped Ukraine needs to be shot down instantly

"Real problem with the Palestinians: Nobody wants them"

ACDC & The Rolling Stones - Rock Me Baby

Magnus Carlsen gives a London System lesson!

"The Democrats Are Suffering Through a Drought of Generational Talent"

7 Tactics Of The Enemy To Weaken Your Faith

Strange And Biblical Events Are Happening

Every year ... BusiesT casino gambling day -- in Las Vegas

Trump’s DOGE Plan Is Legally Untouchable—Elon Musk Holds the Scalpel

Palestinians: What do you think of the Trump plan for Gaza?

What Happens Inside Gaza’s Secret Tunnels? | Unpacked

Hamas Torture Bodycam Footage: "These Monsters Filmed it All" | IDF Warfighter Doron Keidar, Ep. 225

EXPOSED: The Dark Truth About the Hostages in Gaza

New Task Force Ready To Expose Dark Secrets

Egypt Amasses Forces on Israel’s Southern Border | World War 3 About to Start?

"Trump wants to dismantle the Education Department. Here’s how it would work"

test

"Federal Workers Concerned That Returning To Office Will Interfere With Them Not Working"

"Yes, the Democrats Have a Governing Problem – They Blame America First, Then Govern Accordingly"

"Trump and His New Frenemies, Abroad and at Home"

"The Left’s Sin Is of Omission and Lost Opportunity"

"How Trump’s team will break down the woke bureaucracy"

Pete Hegseth will be confirmed in a few minutes

"Greg Gutfeld Cooks Jessica Tarlov and Liberal Media in Brilliant Take on Trump's First Day"

"They Gave Trump the Center, and He Took It"


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

Historical
See other Historical Articles

Title: U.S. leaders knew we didn’t have to drop atomic bombs on Japan to win the war. We did it anyway
Source: Los Angeles Times
URL Source: https://www.latimes.com/opinion/sto ... anniversary-japan-atomic-bombs
Published: Jul 25, 2023
Author: Gar Alperovitz and Martin J. Sherwin
Post Date: 2023-07-25 00:17:26 by Charles_Byrd
Keywords: None
Views: 493
Comments: 6

At a time when Americans are reassessing so many painful aspects of our nation’s past, it is an opportune moment to have an honest national conversation about our use of nuclear weapons on Japanese cities in August 1945. The fateful decision to inaugurate the nuclear age fundamentally changed the course of modern history, and it continues to threaten our survival. As the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists’ Doomsday Clock warns us, the world is now closer to nuclear annihilation than at any time since 1947.

The accepted wisdom in the United States for the last 75 years has been that dropping the bombs on Hiroshima on Aug. 6, 1945, and on Nagasaki three days later was the only way to end the World War II without an invasion that would have cost hundreds of thousands of American and perhaps millions of Japanese lives. Not only did the bombs end the war, the logic goes, they did so in the most humane way possible.

Click for Full Text!

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

#1. To: Charles_Byrd (#0)

We had to drop the atomic bombs if we didn't want millions of casualties on both sides in a prolonged war. The bomb ended it swiftly, and was the Right Thing To Do.

Vicomte13  posted on  2023-07-25   10:43:45 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#2. To: Vicomte13 (#1)

The Japanese were going to surrender anyway.

Charles_Byrd  posted on  2023-07-25   20:38:46 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#3. To: Charles_Byrd (#2)

Every day that the war went on, 10000 more Chinese died under the Japanese occupation. The Japanese were the invaders, and as long as they stubbornly held on, thousands of innocent people were dying every day. There was NO REASON to let the Japanese keep their dignity. They were "going to surrender anyway"...WHEN? Let another ten days past, and as many innocent Chinese would have died than Japanese died at Hiroshima.

No.

The bombs broke the Japanese spirit and caused them to recoil in SUDDEN terror, and SUDDENLY surrender, at the Emperor's behest. They went from proud, arrogant, murderous bastards, ACTUALLY MURDERING 10,000 Chinese every day, to cringing beaten dogs on their knees begging for their own lives...which we magnanimously granted them. That war had to end RIGHT THEN. NOT when the Japanese finally decided to concede defeat.

They MAY have conceded defeat in October, when the invasion fleet was at the door. By then, another 600,000 Chinese would be dead.

No. Dropping the atomic bomb saved Chinese and American and other Allied lives. It even saved Japanese lives, by forcing the Emperor, in terror, to surrender right then and right there. That was the point. Surrender or it will be the shattering of jade. They did, and that was very, very good for everybody except for Japanese pride, and a handful of Japanese leaders, who were hanged as war criminals - which they WERE.

Any suggestion that Japan be allowed to surrender on its own, without the bombs, means giving Japan more TIME, and the Chinese did not have time. They were innocent. Every day it was prolonged, another 10,000 innocent Chinese died. Versus dropping the bomb and killing 100,000 guilty Japanese, and ending the damned thing in two days.

It was the morally right thing to do. The refusal to see that, and to admit the casual deaths inflicted by the Japanese on everybody they occupied, is either ignorance - you did not realize that there was a price paid for delay - or it is morally bankrupt, valuing Japanese lives OVER the lives of the innocent people they invaded, and the Americans who would have had to dig them out.

"Japan would have surrendered anyway"? WHEN? If it was later than two days, it is not nearly good enough. Sacrificing too many innocent lives to let the Japanese have time to preserve their wounded pride. FUCK Japanese pride. Nuke it.

Vicomte13  posted on  2023-07-26   14:41:45 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#4. To: Charles_Byrd (#2)

"The Japanese were going to surrender anyway."

No evidence of that whatsoever, but plenty of evidence that the thoroughly-propagandized Japanese people would have fought to the death, and tens of thousands--at least--American soldiers would have died in the invasion. Truman made the right call...MUD

"NOW...Devolve Power Outta the Federal Leviathan!!"

Mudboy Slim  posted on  2023-07-26   17:02:22 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#5. To: Mudboy Slim (#4)

They would have fought to the death. And even WITHOUT American casualties in an eventual invasion, 10,000 of our allies, the Chinese, were being killed PER DAY. WHY give Japan "time"? The Chinese had no time. They were dying right then. The bomb caused immediate surrender, which ended the slaughter.

This whole hand wringing about dropping the bomb is immoral. It shows an utter lack of care for the deaths of the innocent people the Japanese were going to go right on slaughtering until they were defeated and ended the war. The bomb ended it in TWO DAYS, saving hundreds of thousands, if not millions of Chinese lives, and all those American lives that would have been lost in the invasion. I don't really care about the Japanese lives, frankly. Once the war was over, I care.

It's like the Germans. German whining about all of the deaths from bombing and Russian invasion? Waaa - waaa - waaa. And the British the Germans bombed? Or the Russians the Germans slaughtered?

Nope. You start a war, you are a criminal, and guess what, the lives of innocent people and cops are more valuable than the lives of criminals. That's the way it is, and it is CORRECT.

Vicomte13  posted on  2023-07-27   14:27:40 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#6. To: Vicomte13 (#5)

"This whole hand wringing about dropping the bomb is immoral."

Just more anti-American propaganda from the Marxist Left...MUD

"NOW...Devolve Power Outta the Federal Leviathan!!"

Mudboy Slim  posted on  2023-07-27   15:38:01 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com