[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Donald Trump Fought For Us. Now It’s Our Turn

Feds IndicT ... Pro-Trump TwiTTer Troll 'Ricky Vaughn' Over Memes --- Shared During 2016 ElecTion

JUST IN - DHS Issues NaTional Terrorism Advisory ... Takes Veiled ShoT aT ConservaTive Media - Trump SupporTers --- AdmiTs They Have No Info To IndicaTe Specific - Credible PloT

Why the US Hispanic conservative movement is surging — even without Trump

BREAKING: Vermont Senator Leahy Taken to the Hospital

Rand Paul speech

The taboo that could break america.

Trump Impeachment DOA in Senate

Seattle Sure Waited a Long Time to Implement This New Policy on Rioting

Prostitute-Amber

Warden/Executioner interview-Charlie Jones

He Reveals What 1950s Men Thought & Did

7 Black Americans Express Their Rage In The 1960s

Jackie Kennedy on MLK: 'That man's terrible' - theGrio

World Mourns Nehru

STaTes Eye ... Allowing Concealed Carry of Guns --- WiThouT a PermiT

FEC Filing of the "Patriot Party"

NYC ouT of conTrol ... 12 sub humans beaT man - sTrip him naked - sTeal everyThing --- in broad daylighT on major inTersectTon

It's This Simple: Liz Cheney Must Go

Rand Paul Wipes the floor with pedophile lover George Stephanopoulos

Worst Fishing Day Ever (Winter Fishing) ***Bad Idea***

Pelosi Wanted Machines Guns

They're Coming to America

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Skipped Biden's Inauguration...And The Reason Is Beyond Idiotic

Bernie Sanders predicts the Democratic Party could be 'wiped out' in the 2022 midterm elections

Larry King ... Television legend --- dies aT age 87

OuTrage over U.S. flag flown upside down ... aT half sTaff at SouTh Maui posT office --- InauguraTion Day

Biden won’t stop them, and neither will cops, until Portland is burned down

SALUTE THE MARINE!!!!!

Trump's greatest legacy: The GOP now represents America's workers

Joe’s ... firsT 17 AcTs --- Of DesTructTon

google is evil

Now wiTh The UniTed StaTes Taken ouT --- They have a glide paTh To “build iT back beTTer” / “susTainabiliTy” / “social justTce” us --- inTo “The GreaT ReseT

DAY ONE: Beijing Biden Kills Keystone Pipeline and Thousands of Jobs, Rejoins Paris Climate Accord, Removed 1776 Project, Vows to Restart Iran’s Nuclear Program, Fed Mask Mandates

Republicans Block Swift Approval of Biden's DHS Pick

President Donald J. Trump Departure Ceremony

Stop the Steal

Feds ArresT Pennsylvania Woman ... Accused of STealing --- Pelosi’s LapTop

Enter the Dumbest Administration on Earth

How Joe Biden Will Open The Floodgates To Transgendering Public Schools

CNN Pushes to Close Down Newsmax TV

tax and regulate

Supreme CourT Deals DemocraTs A Major DefeaT In Texas ... They JusT Ruled ---To RejecT Universal Mail-In BalloTing

EYEWITNESS' ACCOUNT DC

Biden’s party seeks to divide and destroy, not unite and heal

“If You Need All This To Protect Your Inauguration from the People, Maybe the F-ing People Didn’t F-ing Elect You!” – DC Worker Shows Video of Military Checkpoints in City (VIDEO)

Illegal crossing

How Soon Will the Social Security Trust Fund Be Depleted and How Should People Protect Their Retirement Income?

With These Figures, It's No Shock Why Republicans Got Swept by Democrats in Georgia

Domestic Terrorist?" - Leftist BLM Activist Who Stormed Capitol On Jan. 6 Arrested, Charged - John Earle Sullivan


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

Other
See other Other Articles

Title: The Myth of Fact Based Opinions
Source: medium.com
URL Source: https://medium.com/@davemurray_4851 ... ct-based-opinions-79d3de0dc1ee
Published: Apr 27, 2020
Author: Dave Murray
Post Date: 2020-11-02 02:52:54 by Gatlin
Keywords: None
Views: 153
Comments: 3

The Myth of Fact Based Opinions

Some friends were having a discussion about something that both have strong, but different, opinions. They became clearly frustrated and the tone of the discussion turned south. That is what set me to thinking about all this, though this post is not about them at all. The same thing happens to me. It’s just that it was on my mind while I was doing yard work that could have been a fine opportunity for some mindfulness practice. But I couldn’t not think about this. It happens so often to all of us.

Two presumably intelligent people who strongly hold different opinions about a subject. Both believing in the correctness of their view because their view is based upon facts. Their view is so obviously, to them, correct and factual. What are facts? Often people appeal to the authority of a text, or raw data that are their trusted source of facts. They may disagree with the authority of each others text, or challenge the accuracy of each others data and disagree. That is easy to understand, but what about cases where both have access to the same raw data or where they both consider the same text to be factual and authoritative, yet they still disagree?

This shines a bright light upon the idea that our opinions are fact based. Our opinions are based upon the conclusions that we draw from our facts. How do we draw those conclusions? We may think that we are honestly assessing factual data, but we are assessing it through the filter of the opinions we already have. If those opinions are essential to our world view, then it is an earth shaking event if we draw a conclusion that would change that.

Our minds don’t like cognitive dissonance. It is typical that we rationalize and make apology to preserve our point of view when faced with either facts that challenge our view or someone who has a different viewpoint based upon a different conclusion about our common facts or data.

My takeaway from this flow of thoughts is that I must beware of frustration with people who hold “obviously incorrect views” AKA “my views.”

I am fond of saying, mix a teaspoon of sewage with a bottle of fine wine and you get a bottle of sewage. In this case, mix a conclusion filtered by a cherished opinion with a fact and you get an opinion that is in agreement with what I already think and some link with the fact. The idea that the opinion is fact based is less likely than the idea that I found a way to claim support for one of my ideas with a fact.

Why am I so dubious about the concept of fact based opinion? My two thoughtful friends who are so frustrated by the inability of their friend to see the wisdom of their fact based opinions. My frustration, your frustration, about disagreement about fact based opinions. If there was such a thing, there would be no disagreement.

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

#1. To: Gatlin (#0)

When they get old they also can't remember stuff. Like the the other day when you came back. You thought I had changed my post but I hadn't.

A K A Stone  posted on  2020-11-02   8:45:25 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#2. To: A K A Stone (#1)

You thought I had changed my post but I hadn't.

So, you say …

And I have no reason to not believe you – This time.

I repeat – THIS TIME.

Gatlin  posted on  2020-11-02   9:34:26 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#3. To: A K A Stone (#1) (Edited)

Now tell me that you are pleased to have me return.

Since you have seen such a marked increase in posting activity.

Go ahead – Say it …

I know you are thinking it.

Gatlin  posted on  2020-11-02   9:38:23 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com