[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

SiTuaTion UpdaTe – Dec. 4th – Offensive cyber warfare mechanisms acTivaTed ... elecTion ouTcome now bending Toward ---naTional defense scenario

Hunter Biden Laptop Store Owner Speaks Out After Going Into Hiding

Firm That Owns Dominion Voting Systems Received $400 Million From Swiss Bank Account Funded by Communist Chinese Gov & Companies Before Election

Van Morrison, Eric Clapton Enrage the Media

'Wake up! Stand up! This is America!': Restaurant owner interrupts news broadcast, urges resistance to COVID-19 state 'tyranny'

Bowyer v. Ducey

What’s Up, Ruby?… BREAKING: Crooked Operative Filmed Pulling Out Suitcases of Ballots in Georgia After the Room Was Cleared Because of a So-Called Burst Pipe IS IDENTIFIED

Tucker Carlson: ‘We’ve Been Lied to’ About Coronavirus — ‘A Global Fraud that Began Long Before Election Day

Renowned scientist tells Laura Ingraham the Covid-19 vaccine is ‘downright dangerous’ and will send you ‘to your doom’

Episode 1205 Scott Adams: I Tell You How Democrats Pulled off the Perfect (Alleged!) Crime

Leaked video Shows China Forging US Ballots; Will Trump Use Martial Law? | Eye Opener

Investigation of 100-Ballot Sample in Arizona Finds 3% of the Ballots Were Deemed Fraudulent in Favor of Joe Biden – Larger Audit Granted By Court

EVIDENCE

What Do Communist Brainwashing Techniques And COVID-19 Have In Common?

Faggot lover and possible pedophile Joe Biden Urges Americans to Limit Holiday Travel due to Coronavirus

WE GOT IT! — Col. Waldron Confirms US Has a Copy of the Election Night Data ‘Traffic and Packets’ Sent Overseas to Frankfurt!

Nevada 'fraud': 1,500 ‘dead’ voters, 42,248 voted ‘multiple times,’ RV camps as 'homes'

Video: Pope Francis Takes Off The Mask, Says Christianity Never Recognized Private Property As A Right

PRINCE CARPING Prince Harry suggests Covid was ‘punishment from Mother Nature’ as he launches new Netflix-style nature channel

Neuroscience Says Doing This 1 Thing Makes You Just as Happy as Eating 2,000 Chocolate Bars

Lawmakers bristle after Trump threatens defense bill veto

Newsmax Rises On Wave Of Resentment Toward Media — Especially Fox News

What No One Is Saying About The Lockdowns

CBC Journalist Brags About Ratting Out Worshippers at Church

Dr Mark McDonald talks about his patients and how fear is effecting our country. from The Front;ine Doctor's Summit

Episode 1203 Scott Adams: Biden's Foot, Data Anomalies, Opening Schools, Who Took the Utah Monolith?

“Pandemic is Over” – Former Pfizer Chief Science Officer Says “Second Wave” Faked On False-Positive COVID Tests

Johns Hopkins study explodes COVID death hoax; it’s re-labeling on a grand scale

A compilation of twenty alleged election 'facts' that don't pass the smell test

Arizona witness: Truck loads of ballots kept coming in for 10 days after elections officials thought they were done counting votes

Watch a Dominion Representative at Gwinnett County Election Central, responsible for tabulating ballots and certifying results, download data to a USB from the Election Management Server, plug it into a laptop, manipulate the data, then palm the USB.

Don’t Want to Eat Cows? Try “Ethical Cannibalism” Instead

Saudi Journalist In Message To Iran Following Normalization Agreements With Israel: Iran, Not Israel, Is The Enemy Of The Arabs, Destabilizes The Region

Down balloT ... proves --- DemocraTs cheaTed

Catch and Cook your own food (Trout Catch Clean Cook) - Ep 4

LIVE: Arizona State Legislature Holds Public Hearing on 2020 Election

I bought a voting machine....then I hacked it.

Episode 1201 Scott Adams: Watch Me Monetize My Dumbest Critics While Discussing Election Allegations

Trump Reportedly Planning To Announce 2024 Run During Biden’s Inauguration…

Candace Owens Challenges Facebook ‘Fact-Checker’ and Wins: ‘They Lied for Democrats’

“I’m Going to Use 125% of My Energy to Do It” – President Trump Vows to Reveal Massive Voter Fraud and Overturn Results in 2020 Election (VIDEO)

New: FBI requests files of people voting ‘in multiple states’

Update: Data Analyst Says Election Findings Could ‘Easily’ Overturn Results in Three States

Trump Says He’s ‘Ashamed’ to Have Endorsed Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp

BREAKING UPDATE: Judge Timothy Batten Issues Order to Freeze All Dominion Machines in Georgia!

Trump on Election Fraud: The DOJ and FBI Are ‘Missing in Action’

Situation Update - Nov. 27th - DoD vs. CIA firefight in Frankfurt as covert war against the deep state RAGES across the globe

SCOTUS: Democrat Gov. Cuomo’s Coronavirus Restrictions on Houses of Worship Violate First Amendment Rights

Supreme Court Says New York Can't Limit Attendance In Houses of Worship Due To COVID

Kyle Rittenhouse FINALLY Released on $2 Million Cash Bond


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

United States News
See other United States News Articles

Title: Ahmaud Arbery – Did a Georgia DA sabotage any future prosecutions in the case?
Source: Fox News
URL Source: https://www.foxnews.com/opinion/ahm ... e-prosecutions-philip-holloway
Published: May 11, 2020
Author: Philip Holloway
Post Date: 2020-05-11 12:09:20 by misterwhite
Keywords: None
Views: 276
Comments: 10

When I first saw the horrifying video of the shooting death of Ahmaud Arbery, I was sickened to my core. I’ve worked in the criminal justice system since 1989, as a law enforcement officer, prosecutor and defense attorney. I have worked more murders than I care to remember, and I’ve seen all sorts of graphic evidence, yet this video shook me.

I’m not alone. The emotional response to this video caused such an uproar it got the attention of Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp, who immediately offered the assistance of the Georgia Bureau of Investigation (GBI). They, in turn, arrested Travis and Greg McMichael for murder within 48 hours of taking over the investigation.

At face value, this feels like a clear case of murder with an eventual conviction a foregone conclusion. But I’m not sure a conviction is certain. Why? Because of the early involvement of a Georgia district attorney who later dropped an investigative land mine into the case that creates a blueprint for a potential acquittal and will certainly make the prosecution’s job much harder than it needs to be.

According to a May 10 press release from the state Attorney General's Office, in the immediate aftermath of the shooting, DA George Barnhill of the nearby Waycross Judicial Circuit injected himself into the case – where he had, at that time, no jurisdiction – and was instructing local police that he saw no reason to charge anyone. This, of course, before any meaningful investigation into all the facts had occurred.

When the Brunswick district attorney had to recuse herself because Greg McMichael had worked for her as a criminal investigator, Barnhill was brought in to oversee the case.

Barnhill nearly immediately concluded, largely on the basis of video evidence, that there was no probable cause to charge anyone with any crimes. He quickly concluded the shooter was acting in clear self-defense. But he didn’t stop there.

Even though Barnhill himself was eventually recused from the case because he is the father of an assistant DA in Brunswick – upon his departure he dropped a poison pill into the case file that could derail the entire prosecution.

In early April 2020, Barnhill sent a letter to Glynn County Police setting out a detailed analysis of the facts of the case and explained why, under Georgia law, there should be no arrests.

Barnhill’s letter, which seems like a reasoned analysis, concludes these two men acting lawfully wound up defending themselves from a fleeing felon who attacked them.

This is a defense lawyer’s dream. A letter – complete with the official DA’s letterhead – concluding the defendants should never have been arrested. It’s a blueprint for a trial defense that could easily lead to an acquittal.

And there are other problems. Most importantly, the letter is based on erroneous factual assertions and flawed legal conclusions.

First, Barnhill says the McMichaels were lawfully making a citizens’ arrest as authorized by Georgia law. He says they had “solid first hand probable cause” and were in “hot pursuit” of a “burglary suspect.” That simply is not true.

The first shot is clearly heard being fired while Arbery is in front of the truck. There was, in fact, a life or death fight for control of that shotgun – Arbery was trying to disarm his attacker.

Although video has now emerged that shows Arbery entering a nearby house under construction, there is no apparent evidence that he was committing a burglary. At most, this video shows a trespass. Burglary requires an intention to commit a theft or a felony. The video does not show that. Arbery is not seen leaving that construction site with any stolen property.

There’s no way to know for sure why he was at that location, but the fact remains there is no way the McMichaels could have concluded he was a burglar from the mere fact that he had visited, for whatever reason, this house under construction.

Second, Barnhill concludes Arbery “attacks Travis McMichael" and tried to take McMichael’s shotgun away from him and that McMichael was, therefore “allowed to use deadly force to protect himself.” I disagree.

Under Georgia law, a person can’t claim self-defense if they start the fight. Barnhill says he sees on the video that Arbery attacked McMichael after making an abrupt left turn toward where the shotgun-wielding McMichael was standing. This initial altercation occurred in front of the parked pickup truck and out of the view of the camera. There is no way Barnhill could see that from the video.

The first shot is clearly heard being fired while Arbery is in front of the truck. There was, in fact, a life or death fight for control of that shotgun – Arbery was trying to disarm his attacker. I would have done the same thing. Sadly, Arbery lost the fight and lost his life after more close-range blasts from the shotgun.

Barnhill’s letter simply glosses over the fact that the fight for the shotgun took place AFTER McMichael had already shot Arbery.

To be fair, we don’t know exactly what happened in that one second in front of that truck. But absent any other evidence, there is just no time for anything much other to have occurred than for McMichael to have pulled the trigger.

Nevertheless, this letter is a HUGE problem for the GBI and the new prosecutor. It is out in public and fueling the public discussion. And if experienced prosecutors and the head of the GBI – an experienced criminal lawyer (defense and prosecutor) and former judge – can't agree on probable cause for an arrest, I doubt a jury will be able to agree that anyone is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.

Did Barnhill knowingly inject a poison pill into the investigation? If so, why? Was he trying to sabotage any future prosecution?

These are legitimate questions that Barnhill will be called on to answer. Georgia's attorney general has now asked the U.S. Department of Justice to investigate this investigation – including Barnhill's early involvement and his letter.

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

#1. To: All (#0)

Here we go again. White shooter. Black victim. Enraged black community. Facts be damned.

This is a very interesting article, covering things I hadn't heard about. But don't waste your time on it if you've already made up your mind.

misterwhite  posted on  2020-05-11   12:13:31 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#2. To: All (#0)

Although video has now emerged that shows Arbery entering a nearby house under construction, there is no apparent evidence that he was committing a burglary ... Burglary requires an intention to commit a theft or a felony.

Oh, please. Why else would Arbery enter a nearby house under construction? The intent to commit a theft or a felony is inherent in his actions.

misterwhite  posted on  2020-05-11   12:17:52 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#3. To: All (#0)

Barnhill says he sees on the video that Arbery attacked McMichael after making an abrupt left turn toward where the shotgun-wielding McMichael was standing.

What else to conclude? Why turn towards McMichael? To me, rushing an armed individual qualifies as an attack.

misterwhite  posted on  2020-05-11   12:22:20 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#4. To: All (#0)

Arbery was trying to disarm his attacker. I would have done the same thing.

Then you're as stupid as Arbery. How about putting your hands in the air and talking it over?

McMichaels had plenty of opprtunities to gun down Arbery if his intent was to execute him.

misterwhite  posted on  2020-05-11   12:28:28 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#5. To: All (#0)

Barnhill’s letter simply glosses over the fact that the fight for the shotgun took place AFTER McMichael had already shot Arbery.

Say what? The author just finished telling us that "There was, in fact, a life or death fight for control of that shotgun" in front of the truck.

The shotgun fired during the struggle. How does he know Arbery was hit?

misterwhite  posted on  2020-05-11   12:33:46 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#6. To: All (#0)

From another article:

"This family are not strangers to the local criminal justice system. From best we can tell, Ahmauds older brother has gone to prison in the past and is currently in the Glynn jail, without bond, awaiting new felony prosecution. It also appears a cousin has been prosecuted by DA Johnson's office. Ahmaud, the deceased, had a juvenile and adult felony record."

So, no, Ahmaud was not out "jogging". He was recorded walking down the street, stopping, then entering the home under construction. He left then started running (not jogging) down the street.

misterwhite  posted on  2020-05-11   13:20:14 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#7. To: misterwhite (#6)

I can't decide without more evidence. With that said, citizens have the exact same rights as the police. If cops had attempted to stop him for questioning, they too would have had guns drawn. If he moves towards them, they would shoot him. This case will hinge on eyewitness testimony of the sort only eyeballs at windows can give. Aubrey was shot through the hand. If it were me I would have put hands up, or went up to the door of a house and knocked and asked them to call the police, Or ran right past these guys and hope they didn't get lucky if they shot at me. I am not running at a gun, that is stupid. You don't close the distance, you put distance between you and the gun.

THIS IS A TAG LINE...Exercising rights is only radical to two people, Tyrants and Slaves. Which are YOU? Our ignorance has driven us into slavery and we do not recognize it.

jeremiad  posted on  2020-05-13   1:24:58 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#8. To: jeremiad (#7)

Aubrey was a convicted felon and probably figured these guys saw him go into the house under construction. That's burglary, even if he didn't take anything.

He made up his mind that he wasn't going back to prison. Had he succeeded in wrestling away the shotgun, the outcome would have been completely different.

misterwhite  posted on  2020-05-13   10:56:04 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#9. To: All (#0)

Barnhill’s letter, which seems like a reasoned analysis, concludes these two men acting lawfully wound up defending themselves from a fleeing felon who attacked them.

Here's the letter:

https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/6884019-Waycross- DA-Letter-on-Arbery-Shooting-Jp.html

misterwhite  posted on  2020-05-14   10:59:54 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#10. To: misterwhite (#8)

My opinion is, you are correct.

THIS IS A TAG LINE...Exercising rights is only radical to two people, Tyrants and Slaves. Which are YOU? Our ignorance has driven us into slavery and we do not recognize it.

jeremiad  posted on  2020-05-15   15:19:50 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com