LF: 'The woman is a victim!': Trump WALKS BACK proposal that Americans who have abortions should face 'some form of punishment' – saying it's the DOCTORS he wants to see jailed, not pregnant women

Title: 'The woman is a victim!': Trump WALKS BACK proposal that Americans who have abortions should face 'some form of punishment' – saying it's the DOCTORS he wants to see jailed, not pregnant women
Source: Daily Mail Online
URL Source: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art ... orm-punishment-women-them.html
Published: Mar 30, 2016
Author: David Martosko, Us Political Editor For
Post Date: 2016-03-30 18:42:38 by cranky
Keywords: None
Views: 9597
Comments: 87

Donald Trump quickly walked back comments on Wednesday afternoon in which he had said he favored 'some form of punishment' for American women who terminate their pregnancies through abortion.

The billionaire Republican front-runner made that declaration during a noontime town hall TV taping in Wisconsin. Less than four hours later, however, he insisted that he would only hope to see abortion-clinic doctors and other medical personnel prosecuted.

'If Congress were to pass legislation making abortion illegal and the federal courts upheld this legislation, or any state were permitted to ban abortion under state and federal law, the doctor or any other person performing this illegal act upon a woman would be held legally responsible, not the woman,' Trump said in a statement to the press.

'The woman is a victim in this case as is the life in her womb. My position has not changed.'

But hours earlier, when MSNBC anchor Chris Matthews asked him if he would advocate for legal penalties 'for the woman' who chooses an abortion, Trump had answered: 'Yes.'

That comment came during a pre-taped town hall broadcast that wasn't scheduled to air until hours after Trump's about-face nullified it.

GOLD MEDAL IN THE 1,000 METER WALK-BACK: Donald Trump abandoned a position on criminalizing abortion less than four hours after articulating it

JAIL 'EM: Donald Trump, the Republican presidential front-runner, said Wednesday that abortion should be outlawed and legal punishments established for women who terminate their pregnancies

In the intervening hours, while he steered clear of the issue during a campaign appearance in the town of Appleton, Trump's campaign released a statement saying the abortion issue 'is unclear and should be put back into the states for determination.'

Framing abortion as an issue ripe for a return to state-based jurisdiction is political code for overturning Roe v. Wade, the landmark supreme Court decision that forbade states from outlawing the artificial termination of pregnancies.

The move initially signaled that Trump was making a serious bid to undercut Texas Sen. Ted Cruz, who has cornered the voting market on much of the nation's social conservative base.

A Marquette University poll released Wednesday afternoon shows Trump trailing Cruz by 10 points in the Badger State, which will hold its primary election next Tuesday.

Cruz hadn't yet issued a statement about Trump's abortion position when he walked it back. he had his chance in the resulting chaos.

'Once again Donald Trump has demonstrated that he hasn't seriously thought through the issues, and he'll say anything just to get attention,' the tea party firebrand said.

'On the important issue of the sanctity of life, what's far too often neglected is that being pro-life is not simply about the unborn child; it's also about the mother – and creating a culture that respects her and embraces life.'

'Of course we shouldn't be talking about punishing women,' Cruz said. '[W]e should affirm their dignity and the incredible gift they have to bring life into the world.'

In the rubble of a quickly abandoned policy position – executing a 180-degree turn on it before it airs on national television – the net effect was rank confusion.

'I can't speculate about what he was thinking,' Trump spokeswoman Tana Goertz told CNN form the Appleton ballroom where Trump had just wrapped up his remarks.

She speculated that her boss may have meant women who choose abortions should undergo some form of 'social punishment' or 'mental anguish,' not a judicial punishment.

But the ground where Trump landed – prosecuting abortionists and comforting women – matches that of the national pro-life group Susan B. Anthony List, whose president had presaged Trump's turnaround an hour earlier.

Abortion, said Marjorie Dannenfelser, is a form of exploitation of women, not something for which they should be held responsible.

'We have never advocated, in any context, for the punishment of women who undergo abortion,' Dannenfelser said.

'Punishment is solely for the abortionist who profits off of the destruction of one life and the grave wounding of another.'

MAKE IT ILLEGAL: The anti-abortion movement may have a new champion to lead its 40-year-old war to reverse the Supreme Court's Roe v. Wade decision – but will they embrace him or run away?

KEEP CLINICS OPEN: Abortion right activists will be motivated anew by the threat of a Trump presidency

Matthews had cornered the billionaire on the third-rail political issue during the noontime taping in Green Bay.

'Should abortion be punished? This is not something you can dodge,' Matthews asked.

'If you say "Abortion is a crime" or "abortion is murder," you have to deal with it under the law. Should abortion be punished?'

Trump replied that 'people in certain parts of the Republican Party, and conservative Republicans, would say, "Yes, they should be punished".'

Asked for his personal view, Trump called abortion 'a very serious problem, and it's a problem we have to decide on. It's very hard.'

Trump engaged him: 'Are you going to say – well wait, are you going to say put them in jail? Is that the punishment you’re talking about?'

'No, I’m asking you because you say you want to ban it. What does that mean?' Matthews pressed.

Trump ultimately said 'there has to be some form of punishment,' for women who have abortions if the practice were to be outlawed.

'Yes,' Trump answered, nodding, saying the penalty would 'have to be determined.'

'I do take positions on everything else but this is a very complicated position,' the candidate said.

CORNERED: Trump turned the abortion questions back on Chris Matthews (right), asking him how his pro-choice beliefs fell in line with those of the Roman Catholic Church, of which he's a member

Trump has broadly proclaimed his pro-life position during the presidential campaign, after years of toeing a pro-choice line.

Matthews asked him how he would go about banning abortions.

'You go back to a position like they had,' he replied, 'where they would perhaps go to illegal places, but we have to ban it.'

Matthews, an NBC News legend and a Roman Catholic, found himself on defense when Trump needled him about his Christian denomination's teachings.

The Catholic Church staunchly opposes abortion, but does not call for civilian penalties for woman who stray.

Matthews responded that he accepts 'the teaching authority of my church on moral issues' and 'I concur with their moral position.'

'But legally I want to get to the question,' he shifted, drawing a chuckle from Trump.

'It’s not funny,' Matthews said, according to an MSNBC transcript.

'It’s really not funny,' Trump countered. 'What do you say about your church? They’re very, very strict.'

'The church make their moral judgments, but you’re running for President of the United States,' the host countered.

OUTRAGE: Trump's Democratic opponents opened up a can of fury online after news of his comments spread

The billionaire real estate guru's political line in the abortion sand could jeopardize his already-tenuous standing with Republican women.

And Democratic front-runner Hillary Clinton pounced on the story, tweeting her disgust in a message signed with '–H,' meaning that she wrote it personally.

'Just when you thought it couldn't get worse,' Clinton tweeted. 'Horrific and telling.'

Her rival Bernie Sanders, a democratic socialist Vermont senator, tweeted: 'Your Republican frontrunner, ladies and gentlemen. Shameful.'

Trump framed the decades-long U.S. abortion fight on Wednesday as a crucial matter for voters to decide through the ballot box, since the next president will determine the political balance of the U.S. Supreme Court.

'They've set the law and, frankly, the judges,' he said.

'You're going to have a very big election coming up for that reason – because you have judges where it’s a real tipping point and with the loss of Scalia, who was a very strong conservative, this presidential election is going to be very important,' he said.

'When you say "What's the law?" nobody knows what the law is going to be. It depends on who gets elected.'

Trump announced his conservative transformation on abortion rights last August, saying that Planned Parenthood, the nation's most active abortion clinic organization, should be de-funded at the federal government level.

'The problem that I have with Planned Parenthood is the abortion situation,' he said then. 'It is like an abortion factory, frankly.'

THREATENED: Planned Parenthood – America's largest abortion provider – and its president both lashed out at Trump on Twitter

Planned Parenthood president Cecile Richards tweeted in the afternoon that Trump 'is vocalizing the motivations of every politician who votes to restrict access to abortion. It's about controlling women.'

'This is a man who genuinely does not care about the health & safety of women - only about his political ambitions,' she wrote.

Ohio Gov. John Kasich spoke to MSNBC's Chuck Todd after Trump made his remarks.

'Of course, women shouldn't be punished' for having abortions,' Kasich said.

'I think probably Donald Trump will figure out a way to say that he didn’t say it, or he was misquoted or whatever, but I don’t think so,' Kasich added.

'I don’t think that’s an appropriate response and it’s a difficult enough situation then to try to punish somebody.'

Further to the political left, Democratic National Committee chairwoman Debbie Wasserman Schultz said in a statement that Trump's 'vileness and contempt for women knows no bounds,' and that the GOP leader would deny women 'the right to make their own decisions about their health care.'

On the other side of the political spectrum, Trump lost the support of the March For Life Education and Defense Fund, which organizes an annual march and lobbying events in Washington, D.C.

'Mr. Trump’s comment today is completely out of touch with the pro-life movement and even more with women who have chosen such a sad thing as abortion,' said Jeanne Mancini, the group's president.

'Being pro-life means wanting what is best for the mother and the baby. Women who choose abortion often do so in desperation and then deeply regret such a decision. No pro-lifer would ever want to punish a woman who has chosen abortion.'

'This is against the very nature of what we are about,' she said. 'We invite a woman who has gone down this route to consider paths to healing, not punishment.'

THE MOMENT DONALD TRUMP TOLD MSNBC THAT WOMEN WHO GET ABORTIONS MAY HAVE TO FACE LEGAL PENALTIES

CHRIS MATTHEWS: Should the woman be punished? For having an abortion?

DONALD TRUMP: Well look.

MATTHEWS: This is not something you can dodge.

TRUMP: It’s not –

MATTHEWS: If you say abortion is a crime or abortion is murder, you have to deal with it under the law. Should abortion be punished?

TRUMP: Well people in certain parts of the Republican party and conservatives Republicans would say, yes they should be punished.

MATTHEWS: How about you?

TRUMP: I would say that it’s a very serious problem and it’s a problem that we have to decide on. It’s very hard –

MATTHEWS: But you’re for banning it.

TRUMP: Are you going to say, well wait, are you going to say put them in jail? Is that the punishment you’re talking about?

MATTHEWS: No I’m asking you because you say you want to ban it. What does that mean?

TRUMP: I am against. I am pro-life. Yes. I am pro-life.

MATTHEWS: How do you ban abortion? How do you actually do it?

TRUMP: You know you’ll go back to a position like where they had where people perhaps will go to illegal places.

MATTHEWS: Yeah.

TRUMP: But you have to ban it. I’m against –

MATTHEWS: Yeah you ban it but they go to someone who flunked out of medical school and-

TRUMP: Are you Catholic?

MATTHEWS: Yes, I think I-I-I

TRUMP: And how do you feel about the Catholic church’s position?

MATTHEWS: I accept the teaching authority of my church on moral issues.

TRUMP: I know, but do you know what their position on abortion is?

MATTHEWS: Yes, I do.

TRUMP: And do you concur with that position?

MATTHEWS: I concur with their moral position but legally I want to get to the question—

TRUMP: No but let me ask you. What do you say about –

MATTHEWS: It’s not funny.

TRUMP: It’s really not funny. What do you say about your church? They’re very very strict.

MATTHEWS: The churches make their moral judgments, but you’re running for President of the United States to become Chief Executive of the United States. Do you believe in punishment for abortion, yes or no, as a principle?

TRUMP: The answer is there has to be some form of punishment.

MATTHEWS: For the woman?

TRUMP: Yes.

MATTHEWS: 10 cents, 10 years, what?

TRUMP: I don’t know. That I don’t know.

MATTHEWS: Well why not, you take positions on everything else.

Isn't Trump allowed to "walk-back" a comment he made only hours before? A comment he made in response to a confusing hypothetical?

Chris Matthews' premise was, "Abortion is against the law." Did Matthews mean, "It is illegal to perform an abortion" or "It is illegal to have an abortion"? Or both?

I am not confused about my answer to "Do you believe in punishment for abortion, yes or no, as a principle, for the woman?" being "No" regardless of any premises that may have been aired earlier in the conversation.

If the law stated that it was illegal for a woman to have an abortion, and the woman had an abortion, didn't she violate the law? Shouldn't she be punished for violating the law?

If you keep avoiding the question, you give me a very good reason not to post to you.

It's the first time you've asked that question. My answers are yes and yes. And I'm still not confused, unlike you and your Fearless Leader.

#65: 'If the law stated that it was illegal for a woman to have an abortion, and the woman had an abortion, didn't she violate the law? Shouldn't she be punished for violating the law?'

#57: 'Chris Matthews' premise was, "Abortion is against the law." Did Matthews mean, "It is illegal to perform an abortion" or "It is illegal to have an abortion"? Or both?'

Trump wasn't asked any of the questions you've asked. He was asked, "Do you believe in punishment for abortion, yes or no, as a principle, for the woman?" His answer was "Yes"; as I've already posted (#64) my answer is "No".

That's my point. If there is "punishment for abortion" that means abortion is against the law, right? And if Matthews is asking Trump if the woman should be punished, why would he ask that unless it was against the law for the woman to have an abortion?

So Trump assumed Matthews was asking if Trump would enforce the law. Trump said he would. So did you.

The question without the clauses is, "Do you believe in punishment for abortion for the woman?"

So, yes. The question does assume there is punishment. Trump was asked if the punishment should be applied (to the woman). If she broke the law, what's he supposed to say? No?

If Matthews was interested in learning Trump's position (rather than trying to play gotcha games) he would have asked, "If abortion is made illegal, do you believe the law should target the women?"

The discussion is in the context IF Roe were to be overturned, and IF abortion were legally defined as the crime of murder (or infanticide), under that circumstance, should abortion be punished?

Not to mention that his final question you quote didn't depend on any premise - it makes no sense to ask "Do you believe ... as a principle" if the premises are already given.