[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Freepers Still Love war

Parody ... Jump / Trump --- van Halen jump

"The Democrat Meltdown Continues"

"Yes, We Need Deportations Without Due Process"

"Trump's Tariff Play Smart, Strategic, Working"

"Leftists Make Desperate Attempt to Discredit Photo of Abrego Garcia's MS-13 Tattoos. Here Are Receipts"

"Trump Administration Freezes $2 Billion After Harvard Refuses to Meet Demands"on After Harvard Refuses to Meet Demands

"Doctors Committing Insurance Fraud to Conceal Trans Procedures, Texas Children’s Whistleblower Testifies"

"Left Using '8647' Symbol for Violence Against Trump, Musk"

KawasakiÂ’s new rideable robohorse is straight out of a sci-fi novel

"Trade should work for America, not rule it"

"The Stakes Couldn’t Be Higher in Wisconsin’s Supreme Court Race – What’s at Risk for the GOP"

"How Trump caught big-government fans in their own trap"

‘Are You Prepared for Violence?’

Greek Orthodox Archbishop gives President Trump a Cross, tells him "Make America Invincible"

"Trump signs executive order eliminating the Department of Education!!!"

"If AOC Is the Democratic Future, the Party Is Even Worse Off Than We Think"

"Ending EPA Overreach"

Closest Look Ever at How Pyramids Were Built

Moment the SpaceX crew Meets Stranded ISS Crew

The Exodus Pharaoh EXPLAINED!

Did the Israelites Really Cross the Red Sea? Stunning Evidence of the Location of Red Sea Crossing!

Are we experiencing a Triumph of Orthodoxy?

Judge Napolitano with Konstantin Malofeev (Moscow, Russia)

"Trump Administration Cancels Most USAID Programs, Folds Others into State Department"

Introducing Manus: The General AI Agent

"Chinese Spies in Our Military? Straight to Jail"

Any suggestion that the USA and NATO are "Helping" or have ever helped Ukraine needs to be shot down instantly

"Real problem with the Palestinians: Nobody wants them"

ACDC & The Rolling Stones - Rock Me Baby

Magnus Carlsen gives a London System lesson!

"The Democrats Are Suffering Through a Drought of Generational Talent"

7 Tactics Of The Enemy To Weaken Your Faith

Strange And Biblical Events Are Happening

Every year ... BusiesT casino gambling day -- in Las Vegas

Trump’s DOGE Plan Is Legally Untouchable—Elon Musk Holds the Scalpel

Palestinians: What do you think of the Trump plan for Gaza?

What Happens Inside Gaza’s Secret Tunnels? | Unpacked

Hamas Torture Bodycam Footage: "These Monsters Filmed it All" | IDF Warfighter Doron Keidar, Ep. 225

EXPOSED: The Dark Truth About the Hostages in Gaza

New Task Force Ready To Expose Dark Secrets

Egypt Amasses Forces on Israel’s Southern Border | World War 3 About to Start?

"Trump wants to dismantle the Education Department. Here’s how it would work"

test

"Federal Workers Concerned That Returning To Office Will Interfere With Them Not Working"

"Yes, the Democrats Have a Governing Problem – They Blame America First, Then Govern Accordingly"

"Trump and His New Frenemies, Abroad and at Home"

"The Left’s Sin Is of Omission and Lost Opportunity"

"How Trump’s team will break down the woke bureaucracy"

Pete Hegseth will be confirmed in a few minutes


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

Health/Medical
See other Health/Medical Articles

Title: What we can learn from Singapore's health-care model
Source: Washington Post
URL Source: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dy ... 010/03/03/AR2010030301396.html
Published: Mar 3, 2010
Author: Matt Miller
Post Date: 2010-10-23 13:43:18 by lucysmom
Keywords: government, health care, insurance
Views: 33744
Comments: 52

We interrupt Washington's feud over the president's "way forward" for a brief word on a path not taken, courtesy of the only rich nation that boasts universal coverage with health outcomes better than ours while spending one-fifth as much per person on health care. Introducing (drum roll please): Singapore.

Yes, it's an island city-state of just 5 million people. Yes, it's more or less a benevolent dictatorship. And, yes, until recently, bringing chewing gum into Singapore could land you in jail. But Singapore, a poor country a few decades ago, now boasts a higher per capita income (when adjusted for local purchasing power) than the United States. And here's the astonishing fact: Singapore spends less than 4 percent of its GDP on health care. We spend 17 percent (and Singapore's somewhat younger population doesn't begin to explain the difference). Matching Singapore's performance in our $15 trillion economy would free up $2 trillion a year for other public and private purposes.

Do I have I your attention?

Today we can't find cash to recruit a new generation of great teachers, rebuild our roads and bridges, pay down the national debt, or invest in better airports, high-speed rail, a clean energy revolution or any of a hundred other things sensible patriots know we should do to renew the country. We can't do these things in large part because the Medical Industrial Complex vacuums up every spare dollar in sight. It's only slightly melodramatic to assert that if we could run our health-care system as efficiently as Singapore's, we could solve most of our other problems.

So how does Singapore do it?

Click for Full Text!

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

Begin Trace Mode for Comment # 33.

#2. To: lucysmom (#0) (Edited)

Thanks for posting this.

It is amazing to me that you can read this article and come up with exactly the wrong conclusions. Your ideological blinders are the strongest I've ever seen. It is truly remarkable.

roughly one-third of health spending in Singapore is paid directly by individuals... Singaporeans make these payments out of earnings as well as from health savings accounts

That is correct. They've created a nation of healthcare shoppers who have incentives to spend their own healthcare dollars wisely.

who typically buy catastrophic coverage as well

That's right. So they buy their own catastrophic insurance and then pay for their own incidental medical expenses too. A true nation of healthcare shoppers.

in the United States, by contrast, nearly 90 percent is picked up by third- party insurers, employers and governments

Which is why we don't have incentives to use the system wisely. That is why prices have been escalating out of control ever since the federal government created Medicare and Medicaid. Before Medicare and Medicaid, about 25% of medical expenses were paid out of pocket. We should have increased that to 33% like Singapore. Instead, we decreased it to 10%. We went in the wrong direction.

The system is chock-full of incentives for thrift. If you want a private hospital room, for example, you pay through the nose; most people choose less expensive wards.

Exactly. People have a choice and have to pay for what they choose. This is exactly the opposite of what the left wants in the U.S. -- a one-sized fits all government mandated policy for everyone.

adequate savings for retirement and health expenses are mandated by government

As opposed to government mandating Social Security and Medicare taxes, which puts senior citizens at the mercy of unscrupulous politicians. Many of us have been arguing for privatizing retirement and healthcare savings for at least 30 years and the left keeps demagoguing the issue, which is why we are in so much trouble today.

Public hospitals provide 80 percent of the acute care

Which is not at all the same as Lucy's claims that government facilities provide 80% of all care. Acute care = care rendered in an emergency department, ambulatory care clinic, or other short-term stay facility. Public hospitals in the U.S. also account for a large portion of acute care. My sister is an emergency room nurse in a government hospital in Detroit.

including an ample safety net for the poor

Singapore has strict means testing for government subsidies. The government pays for between 40% and 80% of medical bills for the poor. No matter how poor you are, you are on the hook for paying something out of your medical savings.

Singapore has a wonderful healthcare system. My view is that we should adopt much of it in the U.S. Many conservatives agree. Unfortunately, the American left would never allow anything that gave that much choice and responsibility to individuals.

jwpegler  posted on  2010-10-23   14:27:14 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


#16. To: jwpegler (#2)

It is amazing to me that you can read this article and come up with exactly the wrong conclusions. Your ideological blinders are the strongest I've ever seen. It is truly remarkable.

Back attcha dude.

I never denied that Singapore has mandated health savings accounts or that people also buy catastrophic insurance - that is indeed part of the story.

Again:

But that's only half the story. There's also a massive public role. For starters, adequate savings for retirement and health expenses are mandated by government (employees must sock away 20 percent of earnings each year, to which employers add 13 percent). Public hospitals provide 80 percent of the acute care, setting affordable pricing benchmarks with which private providers compete. Supply-side rules that favor training new family doctors over pricey specialists are more extensive than similar notions Hillary Clinton pushed in the '90s. And in Singapore, if a child is obese, they don't get Rose Garden exhortations from the first lady. They get no lunch and mandatory exercise periods during school.

I know this is really, really difficult for conservatives wedded to all or nothing thinking, however it does appear to be true that government run hospitals in Singapore do act on the private sector to contain prices through competition.

In Singapore all the pieces fit together to make the system they have function well both in terms of quality care and cost containment.

lucysmom  posted on  2010-10-23   20:49:13 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


#20. To: lucysmom (#16) (Edited)

I've already addressed these points many times, but I'll do it again:

adequate savings for retirement and health expenses are mandated by government

As opposed to government mandating Social Security and Medicare taxes, which puts senior citizens at the mercy of unscrupulous politicians. Conservatives have been arguing for privatizing retirement and healthcare savings for at least 30 years and the left keeps demagoguing the issue, which is why those systems are in so much trouble today. The RIGHT wants this. The LEFT in the won't allow it.

Public hospitals provide 80 percent of the acute care

Acute care is care rendered in an emergency department, ambulatory care clinic, or other short-term stay facility. Public and non-profit hospitals in the U.S. also account for a large portion of acute care in the U.S.. My sister is an emergency room nurse in a government hospital in Detroit. Private clinics and hospitals in Singapore provide most episodic care as well as care of chronic illnesses, just like the U.S.

Well over 80% of urban hospitals in the U.S. are non-profit or public. Suburban hospitals are usually more of a mix of public, non-profit, and private. Half of all hospitals in Washington State are public. They are run by local "hospital districts", not the stinking federal government, which is why they work. Many of the rest are non-profit.

The availability of public hospitals is not what keeps prices down in Singapore. At one point, Singapore had a socialist system. They threw it out, implemented market reforms, and prices fell dramatically. People buying their own insurance and paying their own medical bills is what keeps prices down.

pricing benchmarks

Do you know what a benchmark is? It's not a price control as you have repeatedly claimed on this topic in the past. Benchmarking is the process of comparing your organizations processes and performance metrics to other organizations. My company benchmarks a half dozen metrics from 9 of our competitors to gage how we are doing in relationship to industry norms. Singapore's hospitals are required to publish prices and outcomes for every procedure, which makes it easy to compare.

Again, your ideological filter just won't allow you to evaluate the facts in an objective manner. You and your brain-dead leftists buddies would never allow a system with as much freedom and choice as Singapore's. That's why the left has to be booted from power permanently.

jwpegler  posted on  2010-10-24   11:12:08 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


#23. To: jwpegler (#20)

As opposed to government mandating Social Security and Medicare taxes, which puts senior citizens at the mercy of unscrupulous politicians. Conservatives have been arguing for privatizing retirement and healthcare savings for at least 30 years and the left keeps demagoguing the issue, which is why those systems are in so much trouble today. The RIGHT wants this. The LEFT in the won't allow it.

The problem comes in what you do if there's another big market crash. Do you bail out those who've lost their retirement savings because financial companies implode again like they did in 2008? Who do you trust more, unscrupulous politicians who have to directly answer to voters, or unscrupulous heads of companies like AIG who don't?

go65  posted on  2010-10-24   12:17:58 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


#26. To: go65 (#23)

The problem comes in what you do if there's another big market crash.

Just put the money in a savings account / CD. Don't let people put their retirement or health savings in the stock market. It's really simple.

jwpegler  posted on  2010-10-24   12:22:48 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


#29. To: jwpegler (#26)

Just put the money in a savings account / CD. Don't let people put their retirement or health savings in the stock market. It's really simple.

Right, and the banks invest in bum mortages.

The only reason savings accounts are safe is because the government mandates insurance and bails out banks when they screw up big time.

lucysmom  posted on  2010-10-24   12:34:42 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


#31. To: lucysmom (#29) (Edited)

Right, and the banks invest in bum mortages.

Then buy gold and bury it in your back yard.

Geez o pete. Are you so incompetent that you don't know how to take care of yourself?

jwpegler  posted on  2010-10-24   12:46:59 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


#33. To: jwpegler (#31)

Are you so incompetent that you don't know how to take care of yourself?

If I am, then that kind of blows the claim that I know better what to do with my money than government, doesn't it.

lucysmom  posted on  2010-10-24   12:50:45 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


Replies to Comment # 33.

#35. To: lucysmom (#33)

If I am, then that kind of blows the claim that I know better what to do with my money than government, doesn't it.

I've never seen you claim that. All I see is you agitating for more and more government to take care of you.

jwpegler  posted on  2010-10-24 12:55:57 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


End Trace Mode for Comment # 33.

TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com