[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Communists in China are Afraid of Winnie the Pooh

Dragon-elephant showdown not inevitable

'Angel particle' discovery called milestone

Top 10 Chinese tech and engineering marvels

During Abbas's visit, China proposes peace through development in Middle East

After protests over Satanic monument, city removes all religious symbols from memorial

Conservative Anglicans are close to despair. Is the C of E about to split?

Hungary's leader: EU and Soros seek to "Muslimize" Europe

911- Flight 175 Was Not A Commercial Aircraft

Wall Street Journal writer Joseph Rago found dead in his apartment (34 years old)

WATCH: Cop Kills Unarmed Man for Walking Toward Him – Gets Job Back & Immunity

Veterans Turn To Marijuana To Ditch ‘Cocktail Of Drugs’ From The VA

Professor Rages "My University Treated Me Like A Criminal Over A Joke"

Did Elon Musk just confirm that the moon landings were faked?

New Hampshire Decriminalizes Simple Marijuana Possession, Foundation to Nullify Federal Prohibition

Anthony Scaramucci Expected to Be Named White House Communications Director

White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer Resigns After Trump Shakeup

First of Its Kind ‘Food Sovereignty’ Law Just Legalized Local Food Trade WITHOUT Govt

“I’ve Done A Bad Thing” 5-year-old Girl Bursts into Tears As Cops Fine Her for Lemonade Stand

Police Devise New Revenue Scam by Citing People Who Forget to Press Crosswalk Button

Billionaire GOP donor calls President Trump 'an abortion of a human being'

Here’s Who Will Lament — and Celebrate — the Plummeting U.S. Birth Rate

In Landmark Move, GOP Congress Calls Climate Change ‘Direct Threat’ to Security

John McCain Is a National Treasure

Second Monumental Arch of Titus

‘Oh, he just died’: Teens mock drowning man in disturbing video

Body Camera Video In Minneapolis Dog Shooting Released

The good people that Vic talks about needing welfare

Michigan Man Told To “Give Up Some Of Your Constitutional Rights” In Exchange For Adopting Grandson

Court Rules That Employees Can’t Be Fired For Medical Marijuana

Court Says Gov't Has To Do More Than Say It Doesn't Believe The Property Owners If It Wants To Keep The Cash It Seized

Megyn Kelly’s Bad News Just Keeps On Coming. She’s Screwed.

US Lawmakers Seek to Throw Citizens in Prison for Decades if They Boycott Israel

Police Claim Damond ‘Ambushed’ Cops-Unarmed in Pajamas-Family Blasts it as ‘Disinformation’

DUI-E Law Now Makes It Illegal to Text, Smoke and Even Eat While Driving

Taking Care of a Friend’s Dog For The Weekend? Better Have a License, NYC Says

DOJ Boss Promises The Return Of Everything That Didn't Work During The Last 40 Years Of Drug Warring

Orthodox Patriarch of Moscow - West is making a mistake

Breaking: O.J. Simpson granted parole

Antifa Leader Arrested in California for June 2016 Sacramento Riot

Bad Leadership 101: Toronto Man Builds Stairway for $550 Instead of $65,000 -- and the City Blocks It

This Poconos Property Manager Helped My Family Keep Our Vacation Home—Until Pennsylvania Shut Her Down

Jeff Sessions Marijuana Obsession vs Trump’s Pledge

Storage Cubby “Criminals”

John McCain diagnosed with Brain Cancer

Big Military Spending Boost Threatens Our Economy and Security

Girl at lemonade stand threatened by a man who said he'd call police for lack of a business license (misterwhite or Gatlin?)

Former Speaker of the House Let Out of Prison Early After Raping Children

Innocent Man Freed After Cop Seen on Own Body Cam Planting Drugs to Frame Him

Jilted Dentist Calls CPS on Mom


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

U.S. Constitution
See other U.S. Constitution Articles

Title: Appellate Court Rules Government Officials Opening Meetings With Prayer Is Unconstitutional
Source: Breitbart
URL Source: http://www.breitbart.com/big-govern ... tings-prayer-unconstitutional/
Published: Jul 16, 2017
Author: Penny Starr
Post Date: 2017-07-16 16:13:17 by cranky
Keywords: None
Views: 32

RICHMOND, VA — The United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit issued a 10-5 decision on Friday ruling that Rowan County, N.C., county commissioners cannot begin official sessions with prayer, the First Liberty Institute announced following the decision. First Liberty represents the county and expressed disappointment that the court ignored precedent in the Supreme Court’s Town of Greece v. Galloway decision that deemed an opening prayer for legislative bodies acceptable under the Constitution.

“While we are disappointed in the Fourth Circuit’s decision to ban invocations before legislative meetings contrary to Supreme Court precedent, we are encouraged that the split in the vote on the Fourth Circuit demonstrates the need for the Supreme Court review on this issue,” Mike Berry, deputy general counsel for First Liberty, said.

First Liberty is also representing Jackson County, Michigan in a similar case that is currently pending before the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit.

Writing in dissent, Circuit Judge G. Steven Agee pointed out that opening prayer for legislative bodies holds across the country, from the federal to local governments.

“Lawmaker-led prayer finds contemporary validation in the federal government as well,” Agee wrote. “Both houses of Congress allow members to deliver an opening invocation. The congressional record is replete with examples of legislators commencing legislative business with a prayer.”

For the specific case before the Fourth Circuit: “The Rowan County legislative prayer practice falls within the historical traditions recognized in Marsh and Town of Greece and the principles the Supreme Court articulated in both cases,” Agee wrote. “It is constitutional.”

But the majority came to another conclusion, one that, if taken up by the high court, Rowan County’s prayer practice would likely be upheld, legal analysts say.

“We conclude that the Constitution does not allow what happened in Rowan County,” J. Harvie Wilkinson III wrote for the majority. “The prayer practice served to identify the government with Christianity and risked conveying to citizens of minority faiths a message of exclusion.

“And because the commissioners were the exclusive prayer-givers, Rowan County’s invocation practice falls well outside the more inclusive, minister-oriented practice of legislative prayer described in Town of Greece,” Wilkinson wrote. “Indeed, if elected representatives invite their constituents to participate in prayers invoking a single faith for meeting upon meeting, year after year, it is difficult to imagine constitutional limits to sectarian prayer practice.”

The plaintiffs in the case “alleged that the prayer practice unconstitutionally affiliated the Board with one particular faith and caused them to feel excluded as ‘outsiders.’ In addition, they alleged that the overall atmosphere was coercive, requiring them to participate so they ‘would not stand out’ … or otherwise be singled out in a manner they speculated might negatively affect business before the board.”

A review of those supporting the plaintiff’s case reveals the motivation behind it, which includes the Americans United for Separation of Church and State, the American Humanist Association, Anti-Defamation League, and the Freedom from Religion Foundation.

First Liberty was joined in its case by religious liberty advocates, including the United States Justice Foundation, the Conservative Legal Defense and Education Fund and several states — West Virginia, Alabama, Arizona, Michigan, Nebraska, Nevada, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina and Texas.

There are currently only three judges on the Fourth Circuit who are conservative. Two of the liberal judges — William Byrd Traxler Jr. and Albert Diaz — joined the conservatives for the five dissenting votes. (1 image)

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com