[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

University of Arizona Says They Have No Relationship with Visiting Scholar Who Identifies as a Hippo

'Cool story bro': Twitter mocks Trump's proud claim that his approval ratings are higher than Obama's

Charlie Sheen reveals he’s behind sale of Babe Ruth’s 1927 World Series ring, 1919 contract

Killer whales suspects in Cape shark killings

SCOTUS Lets Ruling Stand Protecting Second Amendment Rights Following Non-Serious Misdemeanors

Supreme Court backs church in major religious rights case that will lift an outright ban on state funding

Trump Can Win Travel Ban Case at Supreme Court Simply by Enforcing It

Supreme Court Orders States to List Same-Sex Parents on Birth Certificates; Gorsuch Dissents

Federal ‘OPT’ Program Rewards Companies For Hiring 330,000 Foreign College Grads in 2016

Asylum seekers in Canada who fled Trump now trapped in legal limbo

......Liberal Lawyer Gloria Allred Being Sued for FRAUD

President Trump Ends Long Tradition of Celebrating Ramadan in White House

Nebraska Dem official caught on audio: I’m ‘glad’ Scalise was shot, ‘I wish he was f*****g dead’

MARIJUANA AND SUICIDE: A GROWING RISK FOR OUR YOUTH

These mothers of suicides don’t think marijuana is harmless

People Who Smoke Weed Every Day Have More Suicidal Thoughts, Study Says

MARIJUANA USE IS LINKED TO INCREASED SUICIDE RISK

Hacker collective Anonymous releases video claiming that NASA is on the verge of announcing alien life

UN Official: We Should Make Every Effort To Depopulate The Planet

Driver in crash that killed Midview student had marijuana in his system

Insurance study ties legal pot to boost in car crash claims

(Free Republic Archived Retro Thread from 2002): Sneakypete Schools Freepers and Nopardons on Reality Of Bush Family As Statists/RINOs (and NOT "conservative")

Texas mom arrested after children die in hot car

How the CIA Turned Us onto LSD and Heroin: Secrets of America's War on Drugs

Supreme Court limits rights of property owners

Health Care Debate Exposed as a Fraud, Dems and Reps Just United to do Big Pharma's Bidding

The US Criminal “Justice System” is Devoid of Justice

How the Government Conditions Citizens to Obey

The Double Murder of Otto Warmbier

Thousands march at Paris Gay Pride to demand procreation for all

Actor Seth Rogen Mocks Man Who Was Stabbed 9 Times For Supporting Trump

Is Johnny Depp a Rich and Famous James T. Hodgkinson?

Crybaby Actor Who Played ‘Trump Assassin’ in Julius Caesar Play Says Pro-Trump Protesters Left Him ‘Sobbing’

Jessica Alba’s Honest Company Settles False Advertising Lawsuit for $1.5M

Gwyneth Paltrow's Goop gets criticized by NASA over 'healing stickers made with carbon material used to line space suits'

TSA agent caught stealing cash from luggage at Orlando International Airport

New form of carbon discovered that is harder than diamond but flexible as rubber

California Travel Ban May Keep Its Schools Out of Final Four, Football Championship

DHS John Kelly: Islamic Terrorists Are Sincere, So Regulate the Internet

What Police State? Undercover Cops Bust Teens for Selling Bottled Water

3600 Yard Shot HCR 375 CheyTac

Brooklyn threesome killer sobs behind bars over girlfriend’s deceit: ‘I threw my life away for a f---ing lie’

Americans Protest As DHS John Kelly Flip-Flops, Backs H-2B Visa Expansion

James Jaeger: New Documentary “Mainstream” on The Globalist Agenda in Movies

Jury awards man $870K after doctor removed the wrong testicle

Why the Government Fails at Welfare

Women can't revoke consent to sex once underway, NC law states

New York judge still rakes in $175K salary in jail

Former nurse suspected of killing up to 60 children

Rand Paul: Insurance should be available for $1 a day


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

Corrupt Government
See other Corrupt Government Articles

Title: Are ‘Sock Puppets’ Propaganda?
Source: [None]
URL Source: http://www.theamericanconservative.com/are-sock-puppets-propaganda/
Published: May 21, 2012
Author: By Jordan Bloom
Post Date: 2012-05-21 18:07:49 by We The People
Keywords: None
Views: 440

Rep. Adam Smith (D-WA) sure has some strange priorities.

Last week, he formed the left flank of the Amash-Smith coalition to upend the indefinite detention provisions of the National Defense Authorization Act. It failed, 238-182. 

Three days ago, BuzzFeed reported that he had proposed another amendment, along with Texas Republican Mac Thornberry, to “strike the current ban on domestic dissemination” of Pentagon and State Department propaganda:

In a little noticed press release earlier in the week — buried beneath the other high-profile issues in the $642 billion defense bill, including indefinite detention and a prohibition on gay marriage at military installations — Thornberry warned that in the Internet age, the current law “ties the hands of America’s diplomatic officials, military, and others by inhibiting our ability to effectively communicate in a credible way.”

The bill’s supporters say the informational material used overseas to influence foreign audiences is too good to not use at home, and that new techniques are needed to help fight Al-Qaeda, a borderless enemy whose own propaganda reaches Americans online.

Critics of the bill say there are ways to keep America safe without turning the massive information operations apparatus within the federal government against American citizens.

Recognizing that some legal limits on domestic information operations are probably a good thing, it remains clear that the limits in place up until now haven’t exactly prevented either agency from advancing their own agendas in the press.

This is not new. Complete separation of state and media has always been a fallacy; in fact venerable broadcasters like Edward Murrow, who President Kennedy appointed head of the U.S. Information Agency more than a decade after the Smith-Mundt Act‘s passage, have turned to the state messaging apparatus in the face of the perceived market failure of broadcasting to deliver news as anything other than entertainment.

It’s a salient anecdote because a subsidiary of the USIA, Voice of America, provided the pretext for some of the provisions of Smith-Mundt; the bill’s supporters were concerned about how an organ like VOA might be used if it were allowed to broadcast domestically. The first attempt to permanentize the agency was blocked in 1946 by Sen. Robert Taft. Back then, VOA was justified as providing a way to make sure the recipients of our foreign aid knew where it was coming from; hearts and minds and all. Therefore, the assumption went, it was better for academicians and the traditional media to bring it home instead, with an acceptably independent spin. This is a significant development because it extended the antagonistic wartime understanding of information ops–it’s ok to broadcast propaganda over there, but not here–to peacetime.

Now, due primarily to the internet, it’s nearly impossible to separate foreign and domestic dissemination.  If the old Smith-Mundt bill was paranoid in its apparent fear of government leaflet operations over Peoria, the repeal provisions now before the House seem to have a paranoid belief that Al Jazeera’s presence in domestic markets will make Americans unduly skeptical of our current mideast policy of promiscuous military intervention. So why not repeal an ineffective law?

Because this is all about wartime messaging. Repealing portions of the law would only give more cover to the military for violating the spirit of the law, which they already do in several ways. It was revealed earlier this year that the military was engaged in creating armies of social media “sock puppets” to drum up support for its policies. When two USA Today staffers started to look into the propaganda contracting, they found themselves on the receiving end of it.  And the sock puppets are just the automated version of their earlier talking heads.  That is, the Pentagon’s military analysts program, which provided VIP trips to Guantanamo and other perks for retired military officers who would then appear on cable news and reliably tout DoD talking points.

Consistent messaging and a complacent public are enormously important to the war managers at the Pentagon. Not to get all Alex Jones-y, but my favorite example thereof is this lovely white paper from 1980 on Mindwar–”The Psychology of Victory”–co-written by Fox News military analyst Paul Vallely and avowed satanist Michael Aquino. (You’re not allowed to ask if there’s anything wrong with a satanist writing policy briefs on U.S. military information policy, by the way. Aquino dismisses earlier objections as an “absurdly comic opera.”) Nearly every sentence reads like an unholy hate-child of Orwell, Machiavelli, and Freud, but here’s the most relevant:

MindWar must target all participants if it is to be effective. It must not only weaken the enemy; it must strengthen the United States. It strengthens the United States by denying enemy propaganda access to our people, and by explaining and emphasizing to our people the rationale for our national interest in a specific war. 

Under existing United States Law, PSYOP units may not target American citizens. That prohibition is based upon the presumption that “propaganda” is necessarily a lie or at least a misleading half-truth, and that the government has no right to lie to the people. The Propaganda Ministry of Goebbels must not be a part of the American way of life.

Quite right, and so it must be axiomatic of MindWar that it always speaks the truth. Its power lies in its ability to focus recipients’ attention on the truth of the future as well as that of the present. MindWar thus involves the stated promise of the truth that the United States has resolved to make real if it is not already so.

Yet, based on its own actions, the military has already claimed the prerogative to determine that truth, and suppressed two journalists’ ability to contradict it. So why give them even more license to turn the bullhorn on us? (1 image)

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com